This is a world away from our current Intellectual Elite's ken, but it's not so very long before I was born. We used to think big, then - the train is dwarfed by the coal piles. Now the Elites make everyone file Environmental Impact Statements and ask approval. Now Detroit is withered:
But most people think of it as an effect without a cause. Well, as a student of history: when a country's fourth-largest city becomes a ruin, it is not an effect without a cause. People argue all the time about the fall of the Roman Empire. But nobody argues that it was an effect without a cause - a random event, a black swan, not correlated to any other event.The Intellectual Elite is incompetent, even by the standards they set for themselves. A reverse Midas touch, turning gold into lead.
The fall of Detroit is an objective observation. Most people (even on Fox News) do not really connect it with the history of the 20th century, the FDR administration, the tradition of progressive government, the Great Society, John Lindsay, etc, etc. In fact, they try not think about it at all. Why would they? Their history is made of cardboard. Red, white and blue cardboard. So the American TV audience has the choice of (a) the CAP version, which (IMHO) is entirely opaque and meaningless, or (b) brightly colored cardboard. This by itself is more than enough reason for rage.
The pictures at the link are incredible, color photographs from the late 1930s and early 1940s.