There is a *ton* of propaganda about what's happening in Ukraine right now, maybe 80% of it from the Ukranian side. This makes it hard to know what is actually, you know, happening there. This is a very long and very interesting analysis of (a) current situation, (b) Ukraine.Gov motives, (c) Russia.Gov motives, and (d) US.Gov/NATO motives.
Highly, highly recommended.
And this part seems to me to hit center mass:
In my analysis, the Ukrainians are mass mobilizing their civilian population to use them as human shields, and then parade their bodies on Western media. These forces will be poorly armed and trained, and have little military usefulness. They will make it more costly for Russian forces to enter Ukrainian cities, but as I mentioned previously, the Russian solution to this problem is the simply level the city. In the end, all of these armed civilians will die, their cities destroyed, with nothing gained. I believe this is in fact the goal of the Ukrainian leadership, who are being cheered on towards this end either consciously or not by Americans and other Westerners. I think Ukrainian leadership is hoping for Russia to flattened cities and inflict mass deaths among the civilian population for PR purposes. With their mass mobilization of urban populations, the Ukrainian leadership is putting the Russian forces in a similar position that Hamas puts Israel’s IDF in. What Hamas does, is hide their forces in dense urban centers from where they stage attacks on Israel. The Israelis are faced with a dilemma, either they tolerate Hamas’s attacks, or they shoot back which will inevitably inflict civilian casualties. The Palestinians in turn show dead civilians and destroyed building on Western news media with the intention of ruining Israel’s international reputation. Both Hamas and Ukraine are using their civilians as human shields. Civilians throwing Molotov cocktails at Russian tanks will achieve nothing, other than getting themselves killed. This should be obvious. As America is weaponizing its “cancel culture” for foreign policy objectives, Russia will be endless maligned in Western media if the Ukrainian strategy succeeds. Personally I find it quite sick that Westerners are cheering the Ukrainians on with this strategy. What they are doing, whether consciously or not, is to sacrifice endless Ukrainian lives all for a narrative to be built of Ukrainian martyrdom.
Take a half hour to read the whole thing which is best described as (ahem) Borepatchian in length. Or maybe even longer. But there's a ton of food for thought, at least for folks who don't appreciate being manipulated by increasingly transparent propaganda.
And when I say "increasingly transparent propaganda" I really, really mean increasingly transparent propaganda. For example, the "New York Times" journalist who was just killed. The headline?
BREAKING: Award-Winning AMERICAN Filmmaker and Journalist Shot Dead By Russian Troops...Here Are The Details
Wow, just wow.
Except, not so fast. Here's the interesting graf from that very article:
Daily Mail reports – Initially, he was thought to have been on assignment for The New York Times because he was carrying a press badge that listed the newspaper as his publication but it has since emerged he was working on a global film about refugees.
So was he or wasn't he covering things for the NYT? Like I said,
increasingly transparent propaganda that is increasingly disconnected from facts. Certainly this is a tragedy for him and his family - actually the whole damn war is a tragedy for millions and their families - but wartime journalism is known to be a dangerous profession. Remember the
15 journalists killed in the opening weeks of the Iraq war?
Like I said, I would love a higher caliber of news reporting from Ukraine. It feels like the
original link to Alexander's Cartographer is providing what used to be provided by regular journalists. Is it, or is it a more subtle and less obvious propaganda? Who can say?
But it seems that most of what you read is clearly drivel. I'd like a higher caliber drivel, please. Go read the whole thing which does not feel to me like drivel, but rather reasoned discussion.