Monday, June 4, 2012

Reconstruction

An odd thing happened at the end of the War Between the States.  While most of the returning Southern veterans came back to their farms with little animosity to the Yankee armies, withing a few short years resentment was smouldering.  This isn't taught in the public schools, up in Yankeeland.

It should be.

The ferocity of Reconstruction is only hinted at in most textbooks.  You get a flavor of it in Lincoln's second inaugural address:
Yet, if God wills that it continue until all the wealth piled by the bondsman's two hundred and fifty years of unrequited toil shall be sunk, and until every drop of blood drawn with the lash shall be paid by another drawn with the sword, as was said three thousand years ago, so still it must be said "the judgments of the Lord are true and righteous altogether."
Reconstruction was intended to be a scourge.  You get a flavor of this in the impeachment of Andrew Johnson.  But all of this is only a flavor, and doesn't give a visceral feeling of the ferocity of the program.  Without that visceral feeling, there's simply no way to understand the hatred (the word is not too strong) that two generations felt.

As a public service to Yankees, here is a visual guide to help you feel that ferocity.  Exhibit A, the veteran's cemetery in Marietta, GA:

Photo copyright Borepatch
This is a beautiful site with well maintained grounds, the final resting place of thousands of Billy Sherman's men (and also veterans from subsequent conflicts).  Of the War Between The States casualties, only Union dead are buried here*.  You find the Confederate dead in Marietta's Confederate cemetery:

Photo copyright Borepatch
The difference is not so much in the poverty of the landscaping, although that's a minor sign.  Rather, it is in the fact that 80% of the graves are for unknown soldiers.  Therein lies the tale.

Most of the dead were identified when they were originally buried in 1864.  They had wooden markers placed on their graves, with the name of the deceased painted on it.  The war ended, and work began on the Union cemetery - much time was spent in Washington D.C. on veterans, and the Pension building was designed so that the staircases had a shallow rise, to make it easier for old veterans to climb to higher floors.  The GAR was a powerful political force, numbering 400,000 as late as 1890, and a considerable portion of the Federal budget was devoted to veteran's benefits.

But only in the North.  In Marietta, the town had been devastated, and the people impoverished.  The wooden grave markers were scavenged for firewood, or the names weathered to invisibility.  The neglect is palpable to this very day, even on Memorial Day weekend (when these photographs were taken).  This is only one small corner of the occupied South, and there are a million stories from that day.  But none of them were taught when I was a lad, and I'd be surprised if they're taught now.  Generations have grown up without a clue to the motivations of a good portion of their country.

* Actually, there's one lone Confederate, buried there by mistake.

8 comments:

RabidAlien said...

Sad, really. I remember enough of highschool history to recall that it was being taught that the Civil War as fought over slavery. This was at a school in deep-south Georgia. Its sad, really...130-odd years gone by, and folks still can't respect the troops for standing up for what they believed in, no matter which side?

Alan said...

Reconstruction is why Damnyankee is one word in the South. It wasn't the war that did that.

Secesh said...

To find out what really happened during "Reconstruction" read "The Tragic Era" by Claude G. Bowers. It's an eyeopener, but may be hard to find.

Andrew Campbell said...

Great post that reminds me of the Churchill quote about the victors writing the history books -- and the difference in the cemeteries is really striking.

Anonymous said...

It is why a certain organization wearing hoods came about and one of it's founding members has a rather good monument and a state park named after him. Nathan Bedford Forrest one of the finest cavalry officers of the entire war. He left the masked avengers organization when it's goals shifted from terrorizing carpet baggers and yankees.
Also Shiloh is the same, fantastic memorials to the fallen from the North and a mass unmarked grave for the South.

Borepatch said...

knottedprop, it's an interesting question as to whether there would have even been a Klan without the ferocity of the Reconstruction program.

That said, there probably would have been. The Klan was quite active in New England through the 1920s, although there they focused their hate on Jews and Catholics.

Anonymous said...

As noted, the victors write the history books.

As a southerner born and bred, I understand the hatred created by the era. As a cognizant man, I also understand no one alive today had anything to do with it.

Its time to move on. Millions of pioneers have unmarked graves, millions of American Indians (oops, Native Americans) as well.

WE can't change the past, we CAN move forward respecting those whom we touch daily.

Lissa said...

Didn't any of y'all read Gone with the Wind?