His departures so far have been generally worthy, and some changes are inevitable when translating a book to film, so I'm willing to grant him some leeway as long as he keeps the quality up.
Plus, as I understand it, many of his additions in this trilogy come from Tolkien's related works (Lost Tales, The Silmarillion, etc.), so they should work pretty well on their own.
5 comments:
The things he changes can be endearing:
Dwarf: You can't outrun Gundabad Wargs!
Radagast: *These* are Rhosgobel Rabbits!
Yeah, OK, sign me up. A bit early to get in line for tickets, but where's the line forming?
I'll wait to see it at United... :-)
I DONT EVEN CARE ABOUT NON-TOLKIENISMS JUST TAKE MY MONEY
His departures so far have been generally worthy, and some changes are inevitable when translating a book to film, so I'm willing to grant him some leeway as long as he keeps the quality up.
Plus, as I understand it, many of his additions in this trilogy come from Tolkien's related works (Lost Tales, The Silmarillion, etc.), so they should work pretty well on their own.
Post a Comment