Friday, August 17, 2012

SWPL in action

You don't get much more SWPL than a symphony orchestra.  I used to like me some symphony myself, back in my SWPL days.

The problem is that the dynamic of SWPL drives it to become a parody of itself:
Two East Cobb high schools have been told they will not be performing with the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra (ASO) in the fall because they lack racial diversity.

The choruses at Lassiter and Walton high schools have been barred from full participation in the ASO's joint holiday concert held in December.

Both schools would still be allowed to send smaller contingents of chorus singers to the performance due to space restrictions.

Cobb Schools spokesperson Jay Dillon told 11 Alive News that, "the schools were informed by Symphony officials that their choruses are not diverse enough, and that the Symphony would be inviting a third, more diverse chorus."

Membership in both choral groups is based upon merit alone.
*blink* *blink*

I guess that we can say that SWPL people don't like white kids.  It's all a bit confusing, and I sure wish that they'd publish a rule book so we can know what's OK and what's not.  But it sure is good that we elected Barack Obama President.  I can feel my soul healing ...

P.S. I leave it as an extra credit assignment to my gentle readers to say whether there is a single African American that plays on the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra.

UPDATE 17 August 2012 14:49: Nick the Blogless does the research I was too lazy to do.  There is ONE African American musician in the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra.  But the Lassiter and Walton High School choruses aren't diverse enough.  Hypocrisy stinks, even when it's wearing White Tie and Tails.

8 comments:

Nick the Blogless said...

Extra credit - There's at least one African-American (two if you include librarians):
http://www.atlantasymphony.org/About/Artists/ASO-Musicians/Stephen-Wilson.aspx

Old NFO said...

Yep, playing it both ways... sigh

Anonymous said...

The new civil war draws one more step closer. The simmering rage and resentment all these stupid actions are going to do is to push the USA into two divided camps which will have to come to blows as who is right. As talking about things is not going to work anymore.

kx59 said...

I do believe we are witnessing the final temper tantrums of political correctness and affirmative action as it edges towards it's illogical conclusion. I expect to see more as November approaches.
You cannot legislate equality, only equal opportunity.

Borepatch said...

kx59, Obama ran in 2008 as the guy who would end that. I expect that he's poisoned the well for the next guy who might actually be able to do that.

Quite frankly, this situation won't change until people think that there's more upside in uniting than there is in dividing.

Dave said...

So...by their own standards, then, the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra isn't diverse enough to perform with itself. (Especially in a city with the racial composition of Atlanta).

All further performances should therefore be cancelled until they can find more musicians from underrepresented groups.

David_76528 said...

Just a quick update:Atlanta Symphony Musicians Offer to Perform for Free with Choral Groups
www.atlsymphonymusicians.com
We, the ATL Symphony Musicians, will perform for free with the Lassiter, Walton, and Grady choral groups at their schools.
Just goes to show some people will still stand up. By the way I love your site.

Borepatch said...

David, thanks for the update, and well done to the musicians.

Glad you like the blog - stop back!