The classic tradeoff is security vs. operations - one group tries to make things hard to break in to, the other just tries to keep things running. This has been summed up as "Keep the bad guys out, let the good guys in, and don't make the wheels fall off."
The problem is that really good security guys are typically good at looking at the trees, not at the forest. When you're creating encryption algorithms that's exactly what you want, but security often fails because a good idea can't scale to hundreds of thousands or millions of systems. Operationally, nobody bothered to figure out how to make it work.
The Heartbleed security bug is showing this. Since the attack can compromise your encryption keys, everyone is rushing out to get new X.509 certificates issued (these are essentially the "ignition keys" for the crypto systems used on the Internet). This is bogging down the companies that issue certificates, but everyone will work through that.
The real problem is that when you get a certificate reissued, the old one gets revoked (i.e. "Nobody should trust that old one, mkay?"). The people who designed this system never seem to have stopped to consider what happens if everybody's certificate gets revoked at once.
Something like half a million web servers are effected by Heartbleed, and all of them will get new certificates. Half a million old certificates will get revoked. The Certificate Revocation List (CRL) will grow to unimagined size - some people are talking maybe over a gigabyte (!).
What this means to you, gentle reader, is that when you take your browser and go surfing to Amazon, there will be an increasing lag that you experience as your browser downloads the latest monster sized CRL. There are protocols that let you look up certificates for validity (OCSP), but we don't have any idea how those will scale when a billion people are hitting the servers. Probably poorly.
Oh well, mustn't grumble. Job security for the security teams, what?
Friday, April 25, 2014
You Americans are all bastards!
This is the greatest line of the greatest Foamy The Squirrel episodes (language NSFW). I'd always treated it a a source of laughs. Well, it's actually true.
I work for a tech company that is global, and by "global" I mean engineering teams in Israel, Massachusetts, Georgia, Texas, Colorado, San Jose, Beijing, and Bangalore. Guess which hours of the day conference calls get scheduled?
You Americans are all bastards ...
Well yesterday I had to brief the global field force on somethingorother. The global field force. Meaning, I had to do it twice, once from an all American, God fearin' time zone and once at Ohmygodthirty for the folks in Asia.
Forgive me, those of you across the International Date Line. I had no idea.
Glurb. Blogging will be (hopefully) a bit humbler today ...
I work for a tech company that is global, and by "global" I mean engineering teams in Israel, Massachusetts, Georgia, Texas, Colorado, San Jose, Beijing, and Bangalore. Guess which hours of the day conference calls get scheduled?
You Americans are all bastards ...
Well yesterday I had to brief the global field force on somethingorother. The global field force. Meaning, I had to do it twice, once from an all American, God fearin' time zone and once at Ohmygodthirty for the folks in Asia.
Forgive me, those of you across the International Date Line. I had no idea.
Glurb. Blogging will be (hopefully) a bit humbler today ...
Thursday, April 24, 2014
When our blood stained the sand and the water
Today is ANZAC day, a holiday that recalls that day 98 years ago when the Tommies from the Australia and New Zealand Army Corps (ANZAC) hit the beaches at Gallipoli.
Muscle, blood, and valor were matched against machine guns. Nearly a century has passed since that terrible day, and all the veterans of the Great War ANZAC have mustered out of this mortal coil, but their courage reminds us that the first rule of war is that young men die. If you have to do it, make sure it's worth it.
Waltzing Matilda, waltzing Matilda,
will you come a'waltzing Matilda with me?
And their ghosts may be heard
as they march by the billabong.
Will you come a'waltzing Matilda with me?
Muscle, blood, and valor were matched against machine guns. Nearly a century has passed since that terrible day, and all the veterans of the Great War ANZAC have mustered out of this mortal coil, but their courage reminds us that the first rule of war is that young men die. If you have to do it, make sure it's worth it.
Waltzing Matilda, waltzing Matilda,
will you come a'waltzing Matilda with me?
And their ghosts may be heard
as they march by the billabong.
Will you come a'waltzing Matilda with me?
Republican Establishment fears Republican voters, not Democratic ones
Georgia's Governor Nathan Deal signs gun liberalization law:
I must confess that I didn't think that Hiz Honor would sign the bill. So the Governor thinks his reelection chances are improved by throwing Moms Demand Action under the bus. This is an interesting data point into what the Establishment thinks that 2014 is shaping up to be.
Markadelphia hardest hit.
Interestingly, Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker seems not to fear the Republican voters:
Gov. Nathan Deal signed legislation today that would vastly expand where Georgians can legally carry firearms, a proposal that has drawn heaps of praise and scorn from outside groups."Outside groups" are calling this the "Guns Everywhere" bill. Neal Boortz had a good line on the radio, saying that this bill "lets a permitted citizen carry a concealed firearm anywhere a non-permitted thug or gang banger carries a concealed firearm today."
“People who follow the rules can protect themselves and their families from people who don’t follow the rules,” said Deal, adding: “The Second Amendment should never be an afterthought. It should reside at the forefronts of our minds.”
I must confess that I didn't think that Hiz Honor would sign the bill. So the Governor thinks his reelection chances are improved by throwing Moms Demand Action under the bus. This is an interesting data point into what the Establishment thinks that 2014 is shaping up to be.
Markadelphia hardest hit.
Interestingly, Wisconsin Governor Scott Walker seems not to fear the Republican voters:
Because we can trust that this wouldn't ever be politicized to seize people's guns.Wisconsin’s governor Scott Walker passed three new laws, addressing domestic violence. The laws include a mandate that police track the incidents where no arrests are made when dealing with a domestic-disturbance call.The laws also make it very clear that there will be a process for seizing an “abuser’s” guns.
...
“This is one more big step toward trying to make sure that for every gun you take away, it’s that much better for (a victim, their) family and friends and loved ones who care about that person,” Walker said.
The inevitable collapse of the Washington DC bureaucracy
The spirit of secession is alive and well, and is global in scope:
They're joined by Catalonia:
Europe, for all its grandiose centralizing plans to counterbalance the American hyperpuissance is falling apart before our eyes. Devolution is the game. Here, we call that secession. The path to that end is not (quite) inevitable, but is where the smart money is betting already in Edinburgh. Soon it will be betting that way in Dallas.
I first broached this topic four years ago:
He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harrass our people, and eat out their substance.
The European centralizing experiment is collapsing. You'll watch it happen this year. Sic transit gloria mundi, and good riddance to bad rubbish. And so to our shores, and the inevitable collapse of the Washington centralizing bureaucracy.
Inevitable is the proper term, and this isn't just me being long on sunshine and kittens. Barack Obama is without doubt the most European US President in history. His use of power is straight out of the playbook of the European "Elite". They're running into massive resistance in Europe and Obama is running into it here on these shores:
But that's all spent now. And to the Dark Ages reference above, plunder is the glue of loyalty. In that post I predicted the current conundrum for the leaders of the Western world:
But power exists to be used, and the bureaus are either slipping beyond Obama's control - running on the autopilot which is the Iron Law - or it's all part of the plan to subjugate the hinterlands. In any event, it's not working as a self-organized Nevada militia stared down the BLM and the states become increasingly restless. This means that smart State politicians see a way to get ahead by getting tough with Washington. Increasingly, it pays to flip the bird to the king.
The Center cannot hold, because a wildly expensive bureaucracy is stifling the Periphery. The Periphery doesn't like it. The cost of the people who keep the Center in power makes it impossible to buy off enough politicians to defuse the Periphery's unrest. It's a dialectic in action.
The natives are restless, and are increasingly so.
And so the smart politics is increasingly one of defiance to the Center. We shall see it later this year in Edinburgh and Barcelona. We will see is to a lesser - but growing - extent in Austin and Pierre. But the trajectory is locked because Obama needs every scrap of his base for this (and the next) election cycle. He'll double down because he has to. That will be throwing gasoline on the fire. And it won't be enough now, as it wasn't in the Dark Ages:
I don't expect that they will ultimately enjoy that.
Bootnote: if you believe that the two political parties are but the two wings of the same bird of prey, then this suggests that President Romney will see this same dynamic continue in 2017 ...
THE list of organisations withdrawing from CBI Scotland over its stance [opposing] the [Scottish independence] referendum grew yesterday, with two more universities among those quitting.Scotland will vote soon on whether to leave the UK. A friend in Edinburgh tells me that it's all over but the vote counting. The periphery is, for better or worse, poised to dissolve the political bands which have connected them with the sassenach.
They're joined by Catalonia:
Catalonia’s president has vowed to press ahead with a fiercely contentious referendum on independence from Spain, warning that he now saw little chance of a negotiated settlement with Madrid that could tackle the region’s economic and political grievances...And the restive populations of Wales, Brittany, and Northern Italy watch with increasing impatience. Belgium looks fair to break apart within a decade, as the unnatural marriage of french speaking Walloons and dutch speaking Flemings continue to keep that national government vapor locked.
Europe, for all its grandiose centralizing plans to counterbalance the American hyperpuissance is falling apart before our eyes. Devolution is the game. Here, we call that secession. The path to that end is not (quite) inevitable, but is where the smart money is betting already in Edinburgh. Soon it will be betting that way in Dallas.
I first broached this topic four years ago:
Kings of [Dark Ages Britain] were Ring Givers, as described in Beowulf and echoed in J.R.R. Tolkien's novels. Simon Schama writes about how the system worked in his A History Of Britain:And so it is today. The modern Kings - David Cameron, Barack Obama, M. van Rampouy - are failing because they struggle to be Ring Givers. Europe has led the charge down this blind alley, and so are running out of rings faster than here in the Colonies, but the plain fact is that Scotland and Catalonia wouldn't even be considering striking out on their own if the political establishment could buy them off. The used to be able to do this, for the last two decades. Now an enormous and enormously expensive bureaucracy in London and Strassbourg has consumed the surplus while tamping down economic growth with stifling regulation. We've see on these shores where that leads.
Their political power rested on the spoils of war and on the unwritten custom of the clan. The blood feud and the inhumation of bodies were standard practice among them. This does not mean, however, that the early Anglo-Saxon kingdoms were places of sub-human brutality and ignorance, perpetuated by thugs in helmets. War was not a sport; it was a system. Its plunder was the glue of loyalty, binding noble warriors and their men to the king. It was the land, held in return for military service, that fed their bellies; it was the honour that fed their pride; and it was the jewels that pandered to their vanity. It was everything.
He has erected a multitude of New Offices, and sent hither swarms of Officers to harrass our people, and eat out their substance.
The European centralizing experiment is collapsing. You'll watch it happen this year. Sic transit gloria mundi, and good riddance to bad rubbish. And so to our shores, and the inevitable collapse of the Washington centralizing bureaucracy.
Inevitable is the proper term, and this isn't just me being long on sunshine and kittens. Barack Obama is without doubt the most European US President in history. His use of power is straight out of the playbook of the European "Elite". They're running into massive resistance in Europe and Obama is running into it here on these shores:
“I am about ready,” [Texas Attorney] General Abbott told Breitbart Texas, “to go to the Red River and raise a ‘Come and Take It’ flag to tell the feds to stay out of Texas.”In a more prosperous day, Washington would have just bought him off. But they can't now, any more than David Cameron can buy off the Scottish politicians or Señor Rajoy Brey can buy off the Catalan politicians. There's no money left. It's all been spent on the coalition that supported each of these leaders ascent to power - the notorious "Stimulus" program was essentially a Trillion dollar payoff to Obama's allies, and he certainly would have not been reelected without that.
...
In an exclusive interview with Breitbart Texas, General Abbott said, “This is the latest line of attack by the Obama Administration where it seems like they have a complete disregard for the rule of law in this country ...And now they’ve crossed the line quite literally by coming into the State of Texas and trying to claim Texas land as federal land. And, as the Attorney General of Texas I am not going to allow this.”
But that's all spent now. And to the Dark Ages reference above, plunder is the glue of loyalty. In that post I predicted the current conundrum for the leaders of the Western world:
The modern Regulatory State has a more subtle (and less brutal) method of getting plunder, but at its heart the system is the same: politics is still about feeding bellies, vanity, and pride. Regulations need Regulators, which gives ample opportunity for patronage. New regulations can be crafted with the help of powerful allies, which gives ample opportunity to flatter egos and let them show their followers that they too can deliver results. Plunder must be distributed, even it it takes the form of intellectual booty.What I missed in that post is the bureaucracy as the natural ally of the centralizing power. The bureaucracy has shown itself to be the creature of the centralizers, with the IRS and the BATF as the poster children for intrusive politization of the organs of the government. And they have been well rewarded for it as 7 of the 10 richest counties in the US are in the Washington DC area.
...
The Regulatory State has led us, step by step, vanity project by vanity project to a massive bubble of Sovereign Debt. Like someone who refinanced their house to take a vacation, the industrialized world is facing a crisis caused by a dynamic that Rædwald understood: the need for rulers to cater to their supporter's money, pride, and vanity.
But power exists to be used, and the bureaus are either slipping beyond Obama's control - running on the autopilot which is the Iron Law - or it's all part of the plan to subjugate the hinterlands. In any event, it's not working as a self-organized Nevada militia stared down the BLM and the states become increasingly restless. This means that smart State politicians see a way to get ahead by getting tough with Washington. Increasingly, it pays to flip the bird to the king.
The Center cannot hold, because a wildly expensive bureaucracy is stifling the Periphery. The Periphery doesn't like it. The cost of the people who keep the Center in power makes it impossible to buy off enough politicians to defuse the Periphery's unrest. It's a dialectic in action.
The natives are restless, and are increasingly so.
And so the smart politics is increasingly one of defiance to the Center. We shall see it later this year in Edinburgh and Barcelona. We will see is to a lesser - but growing - extent in Austin and Pierre. But the trajectory is locked because Obama needs every scrap of his base for this (and the next) election cycle. He'll double down because he has to. That will be throwing gasoline on the fire. And it won't be enough now, as it wasn't in the Dark Ages:
As is the centralizing bubble. In the end, Washington DC will collapse because there is no alternative. There's no plausible scenario where the growth in power and control over the States is sustainable. Things that can't continue don't. I believe that the Class Warfare in this Cold Civil War have so weakened the bands that have bound together the Red and Blue States that the easiest solution will be a split. The Blue States will get Washington, and its bureaucracy, and its cost.War was not a sport; it was a system. Its plunder was the glue of loyalty, binding noble warriors and their men to the king. It was the land, held in return for military service, that fed their bellies; it was the honour that fed their pride; and it was the jewels that pandered to their vanity. It was everything.To keep a large kingdom's fighting men in booty, you had to fight a lot. You also had to fight smart - a king that loses a lot of battles loses his men's loyalty and ultimately his life. The chronicles tell us that the Merovingian boy king Sigebert wept in his saddle as his army was routed. That's what led to the Mayors of the Palace becoming the war leaders and Ring Givers, and that led to the replacement of the Merovingians by the Carolingians. You might say that the Merovingian bubble burst.
I don't expect that they will ultimately enjoy that.
Bootnote: if you believe that the two political parties are but the two wings of the same bird of prey, then this suggests that President Romney will see this same dynamic continue in 2017 ...
Wednesday, April 23, 2014
She was just the receptionist
"Just" the receptionist:
Devolve authority. Push it down all the way to the front line troops. Then watch as you run rings around your Pleistocene competitors.
[Time] magazine had assigned a reporter named Virginia Bennett to find out about “automation in America.” She went to see Remington Rand, whose UNIVAC product was then the epitome of computing coolness…but, “fortunately for us, they weren’t very forthcoming that day.” Walking back to her office, she passed the IBM building, saw the “Defense Calculator” (IBM 701) in the window, and decided to see if IBM would be interested in doing the interview. When she asked the receptionist who she could speak with, the receptionist was smart enough to say, “Well, the head of this company is Mr Watson. He isn’t in the building today, but his son Tom is the president and you can certainly see him.”You can't buy that kind of marketing exposure, and most marketing departments can't deliver it reliably - even IBM's. But someone who was "just" a receptionist - but smart and savvy and given decision making authority - made a big difference.
The resulting article was very powerful publicity for IBM, and surely no help at all for Remington Rand’s relative industry standing. If the receptionist had greeted the reporter with the all-too-typical bureaucratic approach (“The Watsons are very busy men, you’ll have to call Public Relations and make an appointment.”) the outcome would likely have been quite different. Tom Jr notes that his father considered the receptionist position very important, and always chose those women himself.
Devolve authority. Push it down all the way to the front line troops. Then watch as you run rings around your Pleistocene competitors.
What you were never taught about fascism
Benito Mussolini was the founder of the fascist movement (not to be confused with the Fascist movement in Italy, which he also founded). His is a much more interesting story than you've been told:
Nowadays, that would earn you an ewwwww from your sweetheart. So what happened? How did the most famous man in the world end up as, well, what we think of when we think "Mussolini"?
But the movement was no friend to classical liberalism, or the American ideal of Ordered Liberty:
And it will help clarify our own two party fascist system on these shores.
The youngest prime minister in Italian history, Mussolini was an adroit and indefatigable fixer, a formidable wheeler and dealer in a constitutional monarchy which did not become an outright and permanent dictatorship until December 1925, and even then retained elements of unstable pluralism requiring fancy footwork. He became world-renowned as a political miracle worker. Mussolini made the trains run on time, closed down the Mafia, drained the Pontine marshes, and solved the tricky Roman Question, finally settling the political status of the Pope.Cole Porter's original lyrics are deucedly hard to find in any recording: You're the top! You're the great Houdini! You're the top! You are Mussolini!
...
Mussolini was showered with accolades from sundry quarters. Winston Churchill called him "the greatest living legislator." Cole Porter gave him a terrific plug in a hit song. Sigmund Freud sent him an autographed copy of one of his books, inscribed to "the Hero of Culture." The more taciturn Stalin supplied Mussolini with the plans of the May Day parades in Red Square, to help him polish up his Fascist pageants.
Nowadays, that would earn you an ewwwww from your sweetheart. So what happened? How did the most famous man in the world end up as, well, what we think of when we think "Mussolini"?
In the 1930s, the perception of "fascism" in the English-speaking world morphed from an exotic, even chic, Italian novelty into an all-purpose symbol of evil. Under the influence of leftist writers, a view of fascism was disseminated which has remained dominant among intellectuals until today. It goes as follows:The actual situation is much more complex, and subtle, and interesting. Lenin was a great admirer of Mussolini, who started out as a fierce Marxist. But while we are continually told by the Ivy League types that nuance and shades of gray are the key to a true intellect, all this goes out the window when talk turns to fascism.
Fascism is capitalism with the mask off. It's a tool of Big Business, which rules through democracy until it feels mortally threatened, then unleashes fascism. Mussolini and Hitler were put into power by Big Business, because Big Business was challenged by the revolutionary working class. We naturally have to explain, then, how fascism can be a mass movement, and one that is neither led nor organized by Big Business. The explanation is that Fascism does it by fiendishly clever use of ritual and symbol. Fascism as an intellectual doctrine is empty of serious content, or alternatively, its content is an incoherent hodge-podge. Fascism's appeal is a matter of emotions rather than ideas. It relies on hymn-singing, flag-waving, and other mummery, which are nothing more than irrational devices employed by the Fascist leaders who have been paid by Big Business to manipulate the masses.
As Marxists used to say, fascism "appeals to the basest instincts," implying that leftists were at a disadvantage because they could appeal only to noble instincts like envy of the rich. Since it is irrational, fascism is sadistic, nationalist, and racist by nature. Leftist regimes are also invariably sadistic, nationalist, and racist, but that's because of regrettable mistakes or pressure of difficult circumstances. Leftists want what's best but keep meeting unexpected setbacks, whereas fascists have chosen to commit evil.
The consequence of 70 years of indoctrination with a particular leftist view of fascism is that Fascism is now a puzzle. We know how leftists in the 1920s and 1930s thought because we knew people in college whose thinking was almost identical, and because we have read such writers as Sartre, Hemingway, and Orwell.This is a very, very interesting article, which includes the five critical facts about fascism. The two most important (in my opinion) are fascism was a movement whose roots are in the left, and fascism was intellectually sophisticated. Those two are enough to explain 90% of the hatred that socialists hold for it. It's a hatred that you only see between brothers. That and this:
But what were Fascists thinking?
Here we should note a difference between Marxism and Fascism. The leader of a Marxist political movement is always considered by his followers to be a master of theory and a theoretical innovator on the scale of Copernicus. Fascists were less prone to any such delusion. Mussolini was more widely-read than Lenin and a better writer, but Fascist intellectuals did not consider him a major contributor to the body of Fascist theory, more a leader of genius who could distil theory into action.Fascists didn't need an intellectual "elite" as much as the socialists did. Not hard to see which the intellectuals would prefer. Useful Idiots, don't you know?
But the movement was no friend to classical liberalism, or the American ideal of Ordered Liberty:
The fascist moral ideal, upheld by writers from Sorel to Gentile, is something like an inversion of the caricature of a Benthamite liberal. The fascist ideal man is not cautious but brave, not calculating but resolute, not sentimental but ruthless, not preoccupied with personal advantage but fighting for ideals, not seeking comfort but experiencing life intensely. The early Fascists did not know how they would install the social order which would create this "new man," but they were convinced that they had to destroy the bourgeois liberal order which had created his opposite.You've likely never heard almost any of this, except as rumors handed from blog to blog. This traces you through the entire history of Marxism, and socialism, and fascism. It's a long article, but this is quite simply the best thing I've ever read on the subject. You'll want to bookmark this, not just because it will take more than one reading to digest, but also because you can use it to flog any Progressive idiot who ever uses the term "right wing fascist".
And it will help clarify our own two party fascist system on these shores.
Tuesday, April 22, 2014
Why you will always have dead people on the Medicaid and welfare roles
Illinois has spent $12M on Medicaid for dead people:
Now think about the government agency that is responsible to Medicaid. What's their organizational incentive? It's to maximize the number of people on Medicaid. This isn't just job security, but it's the organizational mission and over time the bureau will staff itself with people who are enthusiastic about the mission.
And so, Dear Reader, why would anyone expect the government to police the Medicaid roles? Who wants to do that? Who gets ahead in their career by doing that? The incentive structure ensures that money will be wasted in fabulously huge amounts. In fact, the bureau will do everything in its power to ensure that this waste is not reduced:
A Freedom of Information Act request from the Associated Press uncovered a shocking memo from the Illinois state auditor. The AP found that the Land of Lincoln spent millions of dollars on medical services for the dead.Never going to happen. The reason is the incentive structure of the organizations. Consider a private insurance company: there's a clear incentive to identify people not entitled to receive benefits, as this will directly increase the bottom line. There's a scoring system in place that, while by no means perfect will cause the institution itself to police the roles of the eligible.
The Illinois Medicaid program paid an estimated $12 million for medical services for people listed as deceased in other state records, according to an internal state government memo.
...
“It’s disappointing and somewhat enraging for taxpayers, but it’s not surprising,” Righter said. “I wish this administration would spend more time trying to solve the problems rather than trying to convince taxpayers that they’ve already solved them.”
Now think about the government agency that is responsible to Medicaid. What's their organizational incentive? It's to maximize the number of people on Medicaid. This isn't just job security, but it's the organizational mission and over time the bureau will staff itself with people who are enthusiastic about the mission.
And so, Dear Reader, why would anyone expect the government to police the Medicaid roles? Who wants to do that? Who gets ahead in their career by doing that? The incentive structure ensures that money will be wasted in fabulously huge amounts. In fact, the bureau will do everything in its power to ensure that this waste is not reduced:
It's so cute to listen to Progressives about how government is the only one who can be trusted to supply critical services.Republicans have pressed for the state to use a private company to verify Medicaid eligibility. Maximus Health Services was hired to scrub state Medicaid rolls following 2012 Medicaid-reform legislation. Republicans have said the company was achieving a Medicaid eligibility-removal rate of 40 percent.
But the contract between the company and Gov. Pat Quinn ended last year, and the work was shifted to state employees, after the state’s largest public-employee union objected and an arbitrator ruled the contract should end.
Rebranding "Kill the Jews"
Wow:
Other unfortunate European town names here.
Residents in the Spanish village of Castrillo* Matajudíos (Castrillo Kill the Jews) will vote on Saturday on whether it's time to change the name of their small hamlet in the province of Burgos to something a little less offensive.Good grief. I think it takes Mel Brooks to tell that story.
According to the Diario de Burgos, mayor Lorenzo Rodríguez has called a meeting of the 60 inhabitants to put the case for adopting the village's original moniker - Castrillo Mota de Judíos (Castrillo Hill of the Jews) - after which locals will decide one way or the other.
Other unfortunate European town names here.
The Secession all-you-can-eat buffet
Fondue is a strange thing - it's made from lots (at least three or four) different types of cheeses, along with various spices and other alchemical ingredients. And yet is all melts into a smooth and entirely consistent dish, suitable for sharing in a crazy-hipster-1960s communal vibe. It's essentially a socialist dish, from each according to his cooking ability to each according to his hunger. Which is odd, because it's by definition a melting pot.
Salad is the opposite extreme, and not just because it's veggies instead of milk fat. Each component keeps its own separate identity - carrots are not tomatoes. It gets tossed together, but the sum is composed of the constituent parts which remain separate and essentially distrustful of each other.
The Res Publica Cafe used to feature a melting pot, where people from all sorts of backgrounds came here but blended with a common Americanness. This worked for two centuries as the bonds that brought diverse people together were strengthened, and those who wanted to remain stand offish were shunned until they joined the common weal. America was an idea: We hold these truths to be self-evident, whether you came from London or Bremen or Napoli or Dublin.
No longer. For a generation the melting pot has been double-plus ungood crimethink. The "Salad Bowl" is now what our moral and intellectual superiors favor. Each group (never individuals, always groups) remain their own non-American identity as they are tossed together with other diverse groups. And what we see from this is that the trust required to keep a single society functioning is breaking down.
The Democratic Party's coalition requires a set of victim groups to give it political power. As a result, their favored policies have tried to inhibit the melting pot and reinforce group differences. Minorities are penalized from diverging from accepted behavior for the group - "don't act so White", that sort of thing.
And so the feeling that we're all in this together that was so common in my youth is pretty much used up. The question is, what comes next?
I think that this road that we are on leads to secession. We've already seen a geographical divergence of governance, with Blue states increasingly pushing the Salad Bowl grievance identity politics (limited growth with government distributing the jobs) and with Red states pushing pro-business, pro-growth politics (i.e. melting pot with enough jobs to go around). This will not continue forever: a middle class increasingly under financial pressure will flee the Blue states, increasing the fiscal strain that those governance models experience. At some point the Blue states will demand to be bailed out en masse, and the Red states will refuse.
At this point the split will occur. I expect it will happen within my lifetime.
We face a crisis of governance, a crisis of trust, and a crisis of philosophy. Political groups have gotten ahead by fostering these crises: public sector unions with unsustainable pension benefits, race baiting politicians always pushing the "raciss" line, and a post modern university where racism can only come from whites (even, or perhaps especially, if they are poor). These groups will not try to heal the split; indeed, they have every incentive to make it worse. The "us vs. them" of the salad bowl will see to it that the greens up and leave to a different table, just because they're tired of hearing the carrots tell them what a bunch of bigots leafy vegetables are.
Notice that none of the typical "culture wars" issues will be the driver of this split, it's all the economics of bailout. Where a bailout might have been possible in a higher trust melting pot environment, the bank of social capital will have been exhausted. Long simmering resentments will flare in the strained fiscal environment and suddenly both sides will realize that a divorce will be a relief.
It a massive tragedy of the commons, as the Democratic party squanders the communal capital built up over 200 years. In the span of 50 years it will all have been used up, and the polity will splinter. The irony is that the parts left with the Democrats will look a lot like Europe, but not in the good way of fancy aristocratically commissioned architecture with great food and wine; rather, a society of General Strike, zero job growth, and capital flight.
Damn, I'm sure glad I got out of Massachusetts before they built a Wall.
| Recipes here |
| Image source |
No longer. For a generation the melting pot has been double-plus ungood crimethink. The "Salad Bowl" is now what our moral and intellectual superiors favor. Each group (never individuals, always groups) remain their own non-American identity as they are tossed together with other diverse groups. And what we see from this is that the trust required to keep a single society functioning is breaking down.
The Democratic Party's coalition requires a set of victim groups to give it political power. As a result, their favored policies have tried to inhibit the melting pot and reinforce group differences. Minorities are penalized from diverging from accepted behavior for the group - "don't act so White", that sort of thing.
And so the feeling that we're all in this together that was so common in my youth is pretty much used up. The question is, what comes next?
I think that this road that we are on leads to secession. We've already seen a geographical divergence of governance, with Blue states increasingly pushing the Salad Bowl grievance identity politics (limited growth with government distributing the jobs) and with Red states pushing pro-business, pro-growth politics (i.e. melting pot with enough jobs to go around). This will not continue forever: a middle class increasingly under financial pressure will flee the Blue states, increasing the fiscal strain that those governance models experience. At some point the Blue states will demand to be bailed out en masse, and the Red states will refuse.
At this point the split will occur. I expect it will happen within my lifetime.
We face a crisis of governance, a crisis of trust, and a crisis of philosophy. Political groups have gotten ahead by fostering these crises: public sector unions with unsustainable pension benefits, race baiting politicians always pushing the "raciss" line, and a post modern university where racism can only come from whites (even, or perhaps especially, if they are poor). These groups will not try to heal the split; indeed, they have every incentive to make it worse. The "us vs. them" of the salad bowl will see to it that the greens up and leave to a different table, just because they're tired of hearing the carrots tell them what a bunch of bigots leafy vegetables are.
Notice that none of the typical "culture wars" issues will be the driver of this split, it's all the economics of bailout. Where a bailout might have been possible in a higher trust melting pot environment, the bank of social capital will have been exhausted. Long simmering resentments will flare in the strained fiscal environment and suddenly both sides will realize that a divorce will be a relief.
It a massive tragedy of the commons, as the Democratic party squanders the communal capital built up over 200 years. In the span of 50 years it will all have been used up, and the polity will splinter. The irony is that the parts left with the Democrats will look a lot like Europe, but not in the good way of fancy aristocratically commissioned architecture with great food and wine; rather, a society of General Strike, zero job growth, and capital flight.
Damn, I'm sure glad I got out of Massachusetts before they built a Wall.
The North has used the doctrines of Democracy to destroy self-government. The South applied the principle of conditional federation to cure the evils and to correct the errors of a false interpretation of Democracy...[and the inevitable result of an unfettered federal government will be] the initiative in administration; the function of universal guardian and paymaster; the resources of coercion, intimidation, and corruption; the habit of preferring the public interest of the moment to the established law; .............. a public creditor; a prodigious budget these things will remain to the future government of the Federal Union, and will make it approximate more closely to the imperial than to the republican type of democracy.
- Lord Acton, correspondence to Robert E. Lee
Monday, April 21, 2014
What's better than giving a punk a boot in the gut?
Giving him a knee in the groin. I missed this from early in the year, as some college punk tried to photobomb a weatherman. Hilarity ensues.
That's just beautiful, right there.
That's just beautiful, right there.
The dirty hippies finally find an army they can dig
It looks like the BLM killed 40 head of Bundy's cattle, and damaged a bunch of irrigation infrastructure.
But hey, he had it coming, breaking the law, didn't he? Just like the kid sent to prison for a small amount of weed right? Or not registering for the draft in the 60s, right?
Strange that the Flower Children are now all hip to the Law and Order message.
But hey, he had it coming, breaking the law, didn't he? Just like the kid sent to prison for a small amount of weed right? Or not registering for the draft in the 60s, right?
Strange that the Flower Children are now all hip to the Law and Order message.
We can build it better ... out of Lego
James emails to point to this which is not just fiendishly clever, but has exceedingly high production values.
Sunday, April 20, 2014
Satisfaction
Wolfgang has been to the dog park, the Easter ham* is prepped and ready. The new hedge shears work as advertised; nice sharp blades make short work of the overgrown foliage (and at $29 rather than $329 for the gasoline powered job). And the Spirit moved me for the annual Easter post.
All is well, for a moment. You can almost feel the Grace hovering over Camp Borepatch. It's quite an unusual - and nice - feeling.
* Take one picnic ham. Dust with ground cloves, all spice, and nutmeg. Coat liberally with mustard. sprinkle with ground thyme and mustard seed, then with bread crumbs. Let stand 90 minutes, then roast at 350° for 10-12 minutes per pound along with some cut up potatoes. Serve with some sort of vegetation because Mom would want it that way.
Pure satisfaction.
All is well, for a moment. You can almost feel the Grace hovering over Camp Borepatch. It's quite an unusual - and nice - feeling.
* Take one picnic ham. Dust with ground cloves, all spice, and nutmeg. Coat liberally with mustard. sprinkle with ground thyme and mustard seed, then with bread crumbs. Let stand 90 minutes, then roast at 350° for 10-12 minutes per pound along with some cut up potatoes. Serve with some sort of vegetation because Mom would want it that way.
Pure satisfaction.
Selfish
All my adult life I've been focused on family. Raising kids has been a joy, one to be sure that is not unmingled with tears. But whether this was a needed distraction or whether it was by instinct, it was natural to focus on them rather than myself. While their birthdays are more fun than a barrel of monkeys, I actually don't like my birthday. Not because of any fear of mortality, but because I'm uncomfortable with people making a fuss over me. I'm uncomfortable being in the position of receiving, rather than giving, gifts.
And so to the greatest gift of all, Grace. I find it's easy to forgive others their trespasses, and while it's my obligation to do so, it mostly comes without too much fuss. But forgiving my own trespasses, aye - there's the rub. Looking inward, not outward. Shunning - at least for a moment - the active in favor of the reflective. That's not so easy.
That's uncomfortable. That's receiving, not giving the gift. So much easier to turn towards Roosevelt's arena.
The greatest lies that we tell, we tell to ourselves. This Easter day reminds us to stop being so damn selfish. That Grace was give to everyone, including us. It's all right to unclench the fists of the spirit and forgive even yourself.
And so to the greatest gift of all, Grace. I find it's easy to forgive others their trespasses, and while it's my obligation to do so, it mostly comes without too much fuss. But forgiving my own trespasses, aye - there's the rub. Looking inward, not outward. Shunning - at least for a moment - the active in favor of the reflective. That's not so easy.
The credit belongs to the man who is actually in the arena, whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood; who strives valiantly; who errs, who comes short again and again, because there is no effort without error and shortcoming; but who does actually strive to do the deeds ...It's hard to stop thinking like that, even for a moment. Duty calls, and at least with me Duty is not lightly to be shirked. Especially for family. This makes it easy to focus outwards, and easy to not focus inwards. Because that inward gaze is hard, and might lead to the realization that you need to give that gift of Grace to yourself.
- Theodore Roosevelt, the "Paris Speech"
Stop trying to protect, to rescue, to judge, to manage the lives around you . . . remember that the lives of others are not your business. They are their business. They are God’s business . . . even your own life is not your business. It also is God’s business. Leave it to God. It is an astonishing thought. It can become a life-transforming thought . . . unclench the fists of your spirit and take it easy . . . What deadens us most to God’s presence within us, I think, is the inner dialogue that we are continuously engaged in with ourselves, the endless chatter of human thought. I suspect that there is nothing more crucial to true spiritual comfort . . . than being able from time to time to stop that chatter . . .
- Frederick Buechner, Telling Secrets
That's uncomfortable. That's receiving, not giving the gift. So much easier to turn towards Roosevelt's arena.
... who at the best knows in the end the triumph of high achievement, and who at the worst, if he fails, at least fails while daring greatly, so that his place shall never be with those cold and timid souls who neither know victory nor defeat.There is a pride to be taken in that, but alas we all know where that that pride can lead. Men particularly are raised to be this way (or were when I was young). Likely this is following their natural inclination: to be a man is to be alone. Suck it up, cupcake, you gotta do what you gotta do. And besides, looking inwards is uncomfortable. Better to focus outwards.
But there is another truth, the sister of this one, and it is that every man is an island. It is a truth that often the tolling of a silence reveals even more than the tolling of a bell. We sit in silence with one another, each of us more or less reluctant to speak, for fear that if he does, he may sound like a fool. And beneath that there is of course the deeper fear, which is really a fear of the self rather than of the other, that maybe the truth of it is that indeed he is a fool. The fear that the self that he reveals by speaking may be a self that the others will reject just as in a way he has himself rejected it. So either we do not speak, or we speak not to reveal who we are but to conceal who we are, because words can be used either way of course. Instead of showing ourselves as we truly are, we show ourselves as we believe others want us to be. We wear masks, and with practice we do it better and better, and they serve us well –except that it gets very lonely inside the mask, because inside the mask that each of us wears there is a person who both longs to be known and fears to be known. In this sense every man is an island separated from every other man by fathoms of distrust and duplicity.
- Frederick Beuchner, The Hungering Dark
The greatest lies that we tell, we tell to ourselves. This Easter day reminds us to stop being so damn selfish. That Grace was give to everyone, including us. It's all right to unclench the fists of the spirit and forgive even yourself.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

